Saturday, December 31, 2011

Lokpal: Credit goes to Anna for bringing it up and stalling it!

I would give full credit to Anna Hazare and team for forcing the government to take up the Lokpal vigorously. Finally the government brought one reasonably better, though not perfect, and I believe they tried their best to get it through. If the Anna and team had stopped there, I strongly believe, we should have got the Lokpal and the whole credit would have gone to Anna and team. But what has happened is unfortunate!
Image Courtesy: Outlook India
It is very clear that every body divided on various provisions of the Lokpal! Many of the apprehensions of various political parties, NGOs and general public are genuine too. But when there are many differing views and most of them have genuine concern, it is only obvious that we have to agree to one, finding a middle ground. It is in this light, we should see the government has brought some amendments after discussion in the Lok Sabha incorporating some of the views from other parties. Nothing can be perfect and drawbacks and flaws can be reviewed once it is up and running. It is always possible to press for amendments if any major problem or weakness found later. It is quite unreasonable to expect that every demands should be accepted when government have differing views. After all it is the government whom people have elected and if people are not satisfied or convinced, five years is not too long a time to reconsider their decision!

The adamant stand of Anna Team only helped parties who are not interested to have such an anti-corruption set-ups for their own narrow vested interests. They could stall the bill all together at the expense of Anna Team. They got strength and could hide from public anger against them because of Anna's continued opposition against the bill passed in the Lok Sabha.

1 comment:

  1. Nice observation Dear Musthafa. However I do not see Anna Movement = Lokpal.

    It was not Anna movement, it was Expression of anger of We-The people Of India, that these Politicians have sold the Nation. Every Politician turned Mafia, miner, builder is looting this Country. There is no end to this greedness. So this is an Alarm. An alarm to say that we Indians still have patience to protest Non-Violently. Otherwise if it has been some middle est country, Our Gaddafi must have been killed not thrown shoes up on or slapped only.

    So duty of GOVT was to take it seriously and more than that Sincerely. Infect I would say, there is no need for Lokpal if Our politicians act as Leader. Our constitution is based on the fundamental assumption that: "Member of Parliament" would be Leaders, Social Workers, Farmers, Teachers etc..And because People chooses them, so they assumed that Our People or "We-The People" would not choose Mafias n Criminals. But this is not the case. So that Fundamental stone got move out of Constitution's Building. And cracks are evident.

    Otherwise the Entire Corruption is 6 month Job for PM (CEO of India Inc), Home Minister, CBI, Finance Fraud machinery and people like Nanden Nilekani (IT as Corruption removal tool)....

    How an institution (Lokpal) can substitute another another (Parliament-Cabinet-GOVT Machinery) and can be expected to behave Honest?

    Lots of more to write...But it enough as of now:-)...

    ReplyDelete